Saturday, July 4, 2009

Is Keane better than Coldplay? The answer is...




Why even ask this question? Because its fun.

Keane. At first I liked a few songs but the newest album Perfect Symmetry did not grab me right away. I had always liked a few songs off of their second album "Under the Iron Sea" specifically "Bad Dream", "Hamburg Song" and "Nothing in My Way".

What I realized upon sticking with Perfect Symmetry was that this was a band that (like Coldplay) has an incredible ability to compose thoughtful, provoking, lyrics and combine them with big melodies, that are not only extremely catchy but also very original.

At first....the thought of a band with no guitar player is nothing that excites me especially because guitar is my primary instrument and I have been playing it for 12 years.
There are a few undeniable facts when it comes to Keane.
Tom Chaplin has an absolutely amazing voice. He hits notes with ease and is always right in key. Strong control, never pitchy, and hits highs, lows and beautiful mid range. He reminds a little of David Gilmour on Dark Side of the Moon or Momentary Lapse of Reason. A very angelic, soft, yet full voice. Chaplin's personality also plays a big factor... he is the perfect front man, bringing love, passion and energy to songs that put my infant daughter to sleep, while simultaneously I rock out.

Undeniable # 2
Tim Rice-Oxley. This guy is nothing short of amazing. He is the main writer and brains behind Keane. He also brings piano playing to a new level for a Rock band. Especially live...his keyboard set up is similar to that of today's guitar players, with a pedal board the size of a Cadillac and he runs the show from this dashboard of electronic loops, synth fillers, and bass lines which he will play on some songs while also playing piano. Keane recently added a bass player to their live show (good decision guys) which allows Tim to do more live performing. To the music snob's ears you can hear the difference and it is better. Tim also sings wonderful back up harmonies.

In summary Keane has two brilliant members that drive their success. Songs that will stand the test of time....no question. Huge melodies, insane hooks, tons of emotion, provocative lyrics, and an extremely original approach and sound.

There are not many bands that can use lyrics in a literal way and get through to me. Don't say "I love you more than life" say something like "I could blow through the ceiling my fake plastic love" Make me think about what you are saying...and therefore the beauty of music will allow each listener to become an artist with their own imaginative interpretations. Isn't that what its all about??

Radiohead's Thom Yorke is a musical genius for many reasons but that is number one. You never know what the hell he is talking about but it makes your heart explode with emotions triggered by thoughts that have no ambiguity. True genius...He says "The crackle of pig skin, the dust and the screaming, the yuppies networking" and I feel like I am at church listening to Psalm 45 on how to love people. I don't ask any questions...I just take it for what it is...

Keane, says it like it is..."Oh Crystal Ball, save us all, tell me life is beautiful" usually I'd be like...yeah yeah...spare me....next song please. But I am not even close to feeling that way. Instead I want them to play that chorus 5 times instead of two. By the way, the bridge in Crystal Ball is one of the best bridges I have EVER heard. I could go on about "Crystal ball" alone for 45 minutes.

The point is sometimes there are those bands that fall outside your wheelhouse...but you still love them. Keane is that for me.

Lets talk about Coldplay....

Coldplay is Chris Martin. Will Champion is the drummer. You notice Will during live shows as he sings nice harmonies and is very theatrical. But for all intents and purposes Coldplay is Chris Martin. Coldplay has been on a different track than Keane. Started very slow but then blew up EVERYWHERE. Chris has written some anthems and his best work is no doubt made up from these anthems and his solo acoustic gems.

Songs like "Fix You", "Politik", "Swallowed in the Sea", "Death and All his Friends", "Everythings Not Lost", and "Trouble" are songs that have longevity in them. They are beatiful now and will be in fifty years. However, songs like "Low", "White Shadows", "X&Y", "Yes", and "42" were decent ideas and will be remembered as just that....decent ideas or pretty good songs.

The more I think about Coldplay the more I think they swung and missed with their third album "X&Y". Similar to Keane it seemed as though the third album lost a step for both bands. Each album no doubt has their bright spots but overall do not compare to their debut and sophomore efforts.

Coldplay rebounded in 2008 with their album "Viva La Vida or Death and All His Friends". They brought in high priced producer Brian Eno perhaps in an effort to not duplicate what happened with X&Y. One thing is true, it is not easy to pump out anthem after anthem. Look at U2, the anthem kings. They swing and miss on a regular basis and more often the older they get. Sorry Bono...I want to believe, I really do.

Bottom line is it is not easy. Coldplay has a more abstract approach to songwriting. They try to use fancy chords and ambiguous lyrics (sometimes) but their best songs are the ones that are three chords - D - C - G- that's all you need.

The have some serious hooks without having the obnoxious I am trying to write a hit feeling. Similar to later Beatles records...the hooks didn't disappear but the "Love Me Do" songs did...thank God. Coldplay is a smart band with the ability to play different style songs and still have it be believable...something I think Keane may end up lacking. I don't see Keane executing acoustic blues with a country feel songs, while Coldplay on the other hand can pull it off rather nicely. In the end it boils down to one thing for me....

Connection.

And that is why I think the answer to the question is Keane better than Coldplay is........ YES!

I have seen Coldplay 6 or 7 times. Each show is great however the songs do not connect like Keane's do. I always feel like Chris Martin is over doing it. Even the show has a sense of..."man you guys got too big, too quick". I feel as though Chris would like to be like Bono at a U2 concerts. When U2 plays Bono is the king of the world. When Coldplay plays Chris Martin is like a wild teenager at his first prom.
I think for the people searching for that next big band to love forever and be inspired by...you want to look up at the stage and see the king of the world...not the teenager who drank too much red bull before the show.

Keane. I have seen them once. Tom and Tim were playing their music for one reason...they believe in it and they want people to believe in it as well. Coldplay seems to have the "lets give our fans a great SHOW, they paid a lot for those tickets" feeling. Sorry Chris, if I could spend a week with you I could fix this problem for you, but as of now you still need the help.

Coldplay sells out 20,000 seat arenas in the USA...Keane had about 2000 empty seats at place that holds 5,000 people. WHY? Not sure...don't care.

I'll tell you what. Keane can't record their 4th album soon enough for this guy. I hope they hire a big time producer...maybe they hire Brian Eno! Might not be a bad idea. If they shoot and score on their fourth album I hope it is a HUGE hit in the UK, and hope that in the United States it is a HUGE flop....This way I can go sit
10th row center and bring all my friends. The USA's best kept secret is Keane.

But right now I am thinking of two things.....
#1 How can I get to Montreal Canada on September 20th to see Keane.

#2 I wonder if I should sell my tickets for Coldplay in August. It will be the third time I will see them on the Viva La Vida tour...and if Elbow wasn't opening the tickets would already be on Ebay...

Chris, if you want help give me a call. I will be glad to come out to London for a week and spend time in the studio with you...In fact I have a few songs I could sell you....Seriously though the world is a better place with both bands...When will the next "big band" grace us like these bands did.


But for now...

Keane is better that Coldplay.